“The philosophical position that reality consists of many irreducibly different things — and the political position that many competing groups can coexist — both share a Latin root that simply means 'more than one.'”
Latin pluralis (consisting of more than one) came from plus, pluris (more). Pluralism as a philosophical concept entered English in the early 19th century to describe the view that reality is fundamentally multiple — that there is no single underlying substance or principle from which everything else derives. This contrasted with monism (one substance) and dualism (two substances). Philosophical pluralism holds that the world is genuinely, irreducibly many.
William James championed a 'radical empiricism' and philosophical pluralism in A Pluralistic Universe (1909), arguing against the monism of Hegel's Absolute: the universe was not a unified whole but a plurality of genuinely different things in relations that were themselves genuinely different. James's pluralism was optimistic — a universe of genuine novelty, genuine alternatives, genuine choices. The future was not already written in some cosmic unity.
Political pluralism — the view that a healthy polity accommodates multiple competing groups, values, and ways of life — was developed by thinkers like Robert Dahl (Who Governs?, 1961) and Isaiah Berlin (Two Concepts of Liberty, 1958). Berlin distinguished 'value pluralism' from moral relativism: values can genuinely conflict without one being objectively superior. The conflict is real; it cannot always be resolved; we must negotiate, not conquer.
Religious pluralism — the view that multiple religious traditions can be simultaneously valid — is a separate but related position, associated with John Hick (God and the Universe of Faiths, 1973). Cultural pluralism, legal pluralism, moral pluralism — each extends the same basic claim: there is more than one legitimate form, and the multiplicity is not a problem to be solved but a condition to be managed. Plus, pluris: more than one.
Related Words
Today
Isaiah Berlin's value pluralism is the most important version for public life. He argued that values genuinely conflict — liberty conflicts with equality, justice conflicts with mercy, community conflicts with individuality — and that no harmonious resolution exists. The conflict is real and permanent.
This is uncomfortable. We prefer to believe that all good things can coexist, that the good society resolves all tensions. Berlin said no: politics is the management of irreducible value conflicts. Pluralism is the acceptance that more than one legitimate claim exists and that the competition between them is not a sign of failure but the basic condition of human life together.
Explore more words