μ
mu
Greek
“I.I. Rabi's five-word question—'Who ordered that?'—is the best physics joke ever, and it was asked about a particle nobody predicted.”
The Greek letter mu (μ) is the twelfth letter of the Greek alphabet. In 1936, physicist Carl Anderson and his student Seth Neddermeyer were studying cosmic rays at Caltech when they discovered a mysterious particle leaving tracks in their cloud chambers. It was heavier than an electron but lighter than a proton. Anderson and Neddermeyer initially called it a 'mu meson,' borrowing the Greek letter for a particle between other particles.
The problem was that this meson wasn't supposed to exist. Theory said it couldn't. The Standard Model had no slot for it. When Isidor Isaac Rabi heard about the discovery, he asked the question that defined an entire century of particle physics: 'Who ordered that?' Nobody ordered it. It had no purpose. Yet there it was, decaying in a shower of other particles, demanding explanation.
In 1962, physicists realized the mu meson was not a meson at all—it was a lepton, a completely different category of particle. They reclassified it, kept the name, and dropped the 'meson' part. It became simply the muon. The particle had survived theoretical predictions by existing when it shouldn't, surviving experimental confirmation by being real, and surviving reclassification by keeping its borrowed Greek name.
Today, the muon is one of the fundamental particles of the Standard Model. It's heavier than an electron, decays within microseconds, and arrives at Earth constantly from cosmic rays. Rabi's question—'Who ordered that?'—remains unanswered. Physics still doesn't know why it exists. The particle is named after a letter and lives up to it: mysterious, present, unexplained.
Related Words
Today
The muon exists. It shouldn't. It does anyway. Every second, trillions of them arrive from space, pass through your body, and annihilate. Rabi's question was asked in 1939. Eighty years later, we still don't know the answer.
Science named the particle after admitting it was puzzled. The muon carries confusion in its name.
Explore more words